Country Coach Owners Forum

Country Coach Restoration, Repair & Parts Forums => Country Coach Archive => Topic started by: Travman100_4 on November 29, 2004, 09:21:49 pm

Title: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Travman100_4 on November 29, 2004, 09:21:49 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13150 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13150)
I just ran across this little tidbit, is it possible that someone is finally going to regulate the industry. If you have info that can help you might want to send an email. I have sent an email to Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison with my observations of the many people I have come across who have horror stories which might help in her decision to go farward with a bill to regulate the industry.
................................................................
...snip...

Motorhome Owners - Attention Please
Do you believe that your motorhome is as safe as it can be - that it is as easy to keep "between the ditches" as it should be - that it is put together as well as it could be?

Do you believe that you should have to pay for after-market suspension and/or steering enhancements to a brand new motorhome simply to make that brand new vehicle safe to drive at highway speeds?

Do you believe that driving your motorhome should be a "white knuckle" experience? That a passing vehicle should be able to make you nearly lose control?

Do you accept shoddy workmanship and lies and indifference by the dealer and manufacturer to the defects that were built into your motorhome because the old-timers tell you "that's the way the motorhome industry is" or "all motorhome manufacturers are like that"?

Or do you believe that the manufacturer and dealer of your motorhome should be responsible for producing and selling a reliable - and safe - product?

United States Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison of Texas is requesting correspondence from motorhome owners who have had experiences which make them believe the motorhome industry needs to be regulated, just as the automobile industry has been for decades.

Please send your comments to:

Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison ? 284 Russell Senate Office Building ? Washington, DC 20510 ? Telephone 202-224-5922

E-mail: senator@... (senator@...)
Send a copy to your own senators and representatives as well, both state and federal.
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: C Marshall on November 29, 2004, 10:18:15 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13152 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13152)
I know where you are comming from, but I do'nt think you want "Big Brother" envolved. They will double the price of the coach with rules and regulations and and don't forget about the EPA and the fuel milage folks. Well things are going to change anyway. What we need is for Japan or Germany to start building coaches. Anybody want a Lexus or BMW 11 meter coach? (That weighs 20,000 lbs and gets 15 mpg with diesel/electric combo drive).
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Rheavn on November 30, 2004, 07:52:10 am
Yahoo Message Number: 13164 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13164)
"C. Marshall",

I'm with you. The best way to regulate the motorhome industry is to spend your motorhome dollar very carefully.

JMHO
Steve

Intigue #10673

Quote
I know where you are comming from, but I do'nt think you want "Big

Brother"

Quote
envolved. They will double the price of the coach with rules and

regulations

Quote
and and don't forget about the EPA and the fuel milage folks. Well

things

Quote
are going to change anyway. What we need is for Japan or Germany to

start

Quote
building coaches. Anybody want a Lexus or BMW 11 meter coach?

(That weighs
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Bob Kumza on November 30, 2004, 09:16:44 am
Yahoo Message Number: 13165 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13165)
We don't need more regulation, we need more COMPETITION. We don't need more government, we need LESS. This industry is selling every coach it makes, even if they are junk. As soon as Honda starts building motorhomes, you'll see this industry change overnight, just like the auto industry did. I saw an for the new Honda jet airplane a few months back. Maybe we aren't too far from seeing a Honda motorhome.

BUT, I hate to see more of our American dollars sent overseas - we already have a really big problem with the trade deficit. The best possible solution is for an American company (hopefully Country Coach) to step up to the plate and make a decision to start building a really quality coach - a ZERO DEFECTS coach. If a manufacturer truly designed a Zero Defects process so that every failure or problem resulted in a permanent change to the design or manufacturing process, we would have near-perfect coaches rolling off the assembly line within a year.

The key to fixing the poor coach quality is total commitment to Quality with a Zero Defects process driven by the Free Enterprise system.

Bob Kumza

Quote from: travman100
I just ran across this little tidbit, is it possible that someone

is

Quote
finally going to regulate the industry. If you have info that can > help you might want to send an email. I have sent an email to > Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison with my observations of the many

people

Quote
I have come across who have horror stories which might help in her > decision to go farward with a bill to regulate the industry.
................................................................
...snip...

Motorhome Owners - Attention Please >

Do you believe that your motorhome is as safe as it can be - that

it

Quote
is as easy to keep "between the ditches" as it should be - that it > is put together as well as it could be? >

Do you believe that you should have to pay for after-market > suspension and/or steering enhancements to a brand new motorhome > simply to make that brand new vehicle safe to drive at highway > speeds?

Do you believe that driving your motorhome should be a "white > knuckle" experience? That a passing vehicle should be able to make > you nearly lose control?

Do you accept shoddy workmanship and lies and indifference by the > dealer and manufacturer to the defects that were built into your > motorhome because the old-timers tell you "that's the way the > motorhome industry is" or "all motorhome manufacturers are like > that"?

Or do you believe that the manufacturer and dealer of your

motorhome

Quote
should be responsible for producing and selling a reliable - and > safe - product?

United States Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison of Texas is requesting > correspondence from motorhome owners who have had experiences

which

Quote
make them believe the motorhome industry needs to be regulated,

just

Quote
as the automobile industry has been for decades.

Please send your comments to:

Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison ? 284 Russell Senate Office

Building ?
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Jennylindca on November 30, 2004, 01:03:05 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13178 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13178)
The bottom line is....the bottom line. The RV industry will never improve their product so long as the majority of buyers put up with shoddy workmanship. The corporations are in business to make money.
Period. And they will cut corners as they always have done in order to make the largest profit possible...they know that there are certain parts that they use that will fail and that they will have to replace in nearly every coach, but they use them anyway because it looks better to the investor when they make X# of dollars on each sale. The investors don't look at the amount of money that is spent on repairs at the factory or at the dealerships. Maybe they should do so.

If there were no regulation, there would be no safety innovations in motor vehicles or other items sold to us. There would be no seat belts and, therefore, more deaths in crashes. There would be children choking on parts of toys that fall off, or being injured by some piece of furniture. There would be no regulation of emmisions and those suffering from asthma and other diseases would be even more miserable than they are now...I still won't ever go back to the LA basin...can't breathe there. We do need less government - in areas where there is no safety issue and no harm to citizens. Hmmmm...that is a politica;/religious discussion so will leave it at that.

Bottom line to me in this discussion is that there needs to be regulation of the RV industry because they obviously won't regulate themselves.

Carol
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Bill Gabler on November 30, 2004, 01:36:09 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13181 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13181)
Sounds like the Democrats need another cash cow. Just what we need more regulations.
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Rheavn on November 30, 2004, 02:14:00 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13186 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13186)
Actually Hutchinson is a Republican from Texas.
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Mikeogh@aol Com on November 30, 2004, 03:32:33 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13187 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13187)
Are most coaches made in blue states or red states?
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: C Marshall on November 30, 2004, 03:39:13 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13189 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13189)
Sounds like you want a Mercedes Coach. TWI
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: George Sanders on November 30, 2004, 04:10:49 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13191 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13191)
Carol, I'm not sure that I could disagree more completely.
The investor does see the cost of repairs, redos, and warranty work.
Those are all expenses that come out long before they get to the bottom line.

On the subject of regulation I see it differently. The safty innovations that are in cars today were not invented because they were required. They became required after they were invented. Seat belts, shoulder belts, abs, and air bags all came along because of competitive pressures. Some folks want safe cars and are willing to pay for them. That drove competition for their dollars. Today the regulations do not require that a car be as safe as a Volvo. But the Volvo is there anyway. Customer demand is a much more efficient force than regulation.

The same is true with quality. If everyone wanted the highest quality there would only be one car/RV made. What people want is there own balance between some set of perceived features and benfits. Style. Comfort. Performance. Safety. Value. We all make these decisions and I do not want the government making these important decisions for me.

George Sanders in Birmingham, AL
Allure 31038

Quote from: jennylindca
The bottom line is....the bottom line. The RV industry will never > improve their product so long as the majority of buyers put up with > shoddy workmanship. The corporations are in business to make

money.

Quote
Period. And they will cut corners as they always have done in order > to make the largest profit possible...they know that there are > certain parts that they use that will fail and that they will have

to

Quote
replace in nearly every coach, but they use them anyway because it > looks better to the investor when they make X# of dollars on each > sale. The investors don't look at the amount of money that is

spent

Quote
on repairs at the factory or at the dealerships. Maybe they should > do so.

If there were no regulation, there would be no safety innovations

in

Quote
motor vehicles or other items sold to us. There would be no seat > belts and, therefore, more deaths in crashes. There would be > children choking on parts of toys that fall off, or being injured

by

Quote
some piece of furniture. There would be no regulation of emmisions > and those suffering from asthma and other diseases would be even

more

Quote
miserable than they are now...I still won't ever go back to the LA > basin...can't breathe there. We do need less government - in areas > where there is no safety issue and no harm to citizens.

Hmmmm...that
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Jennylindca on November 30, 2004, 04:32:51 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13192 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13192)
Quote from: Mikeogh@a\.\.\.
Are most coaches made in blue states or red states?
What difference does that make?
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Jennylindca on November 30, 2004, 05:16:12 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13194 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13194)
You have every right to disagree, George. >> The safety innovations were invented, yes, but were not used in vehicles until they were required by regulation - except for maybe Mercedes. Volvo or BMW. They became required after they were invented, but also after people discovered that they worked and the auto companies refused to do anything about it until regulations were passed, much like the CAFE regulations. The seat belts were not installed as standard equipment until the corporations were regulated into doing so.

If customer demand were as strong as regulation, my Explorer would have all of the safety innovations included in the Volvo..at a fair price. It doesn't. I still choose to purchase an American-made vehicle, rather than one from Sweden, though my cousins there might appreciate the business. 8-) My next car will probably be a Ford Escape Hybrid...if it can be towed behind my coach.

Without government regulation, you and I would not have the protections we currently enjoy. I do agree with you that the government is much too intrusive, however, that extraordinary intrusiveness is not in the area of safety, but in social issues.

That said, I do wonder if you can make laws that will cause any corporation to do a better job of building motorcoaches or other RVs. Maybe it has to be a decision made by the corporation; as has been said here many times, CCI needs to institute better quality control and make an effort to use only quality parts...the small parts are the ones that fail us - right height valves, etc. But the laws, if used properly by the consumer, can force corporations into taking action to provide the safety and good quality product for which we pay.

Carol

Quote
Carol, I'm not sure that I could disagree more completely.

The investor does see the cost of repairs, redos, and warranty

work.

Quote
Those are all expenses that come out long before they get to the > bottom line.

On the subject of regulation I see it differently. The safty > innovations that are in cars today were not invented because they > were required. They became required after they were invented.

Seat

Quote
belts, shoulder belts, abs, and air bags all came along because of > competitive pressures. Some folks want safe cars and are willing

to

Quote
pay for them. That drove competition for their dollars. Today the > regulations do not require that a car be as safe as a Volvo. But

the

Quote
Volvo is there anyway. Customer demand is a much more efficient > force than regulation.

The same is true with quality. If everyone wanted the highest > quality there would only be one car/RV made. What people want is > there own balance between some set of perceived features and > benfits. Style. Comfort. Performance. Safety. Value. We all

make

Quote
these decisions and I do not want the government making these > important decisions for me.

George Sanders in Birmingham, AL > Allure 31038

[quote author=jennylindca"

>

> The bottom line is....the bottom line. The RV industry will

never

Quote
improve their product so long as the majority of buyers put up

with

Quote
shoddy workmanship. The corporations are in business to make > money.

> Period. And they will cut corners as they always have done in

order

Quote
to make the largest profit possible...they know that there are > > certain parts that they use that will fail and that they will

have

Quote
to

> replace in nearly every coach, but they use them anyway because

it

Quote
looks better to the investor when they make X# of dollars on each > > sale. The investors don't look at the amount of money that is > spent

> on repairs at the factory or at the dealerships. Maybe they

should

Quote
do so.
>

> If there were no regulation, there would be no safety innovations > in

> motor vehicles or other items sold to us. There would be no seat > > belts and, therefore, more deaths in crashes. There would be > > children choking on parts of toys that fall off, or being injured > by

> some piece of furniture. There would be no regulation of

emmisions

Quote
and those suffering from asthma and other diseases would be even > more

> miserable than they are now...I still won't ever go back to the

LA

Quote
basin...can't breathe there. We do need less government - in

areas

Quote
where there is no safety issue and no harm to citizens.
Hmmmm...that

> is a politica;/religious discussion so will leave it at that.
>>
>

> Bottom line to me in this discussion is that there needs to be > > regulation of the RV industry because they obviously won't

regulate
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Mikeogh@aol Com on November 30, 2004, 05:25:38 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13195 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13195)
No difference. Or at least I don't think it should. It was tongue in cheek.
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Jennylindca on November 30, 2004, 05:50:25 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13197 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13197)
Oh - couldn't see your cheek. >>

Quote
No difference. Or at least I don't think it should. It was
tongue in cheek.
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Bill Gabler on December 01, 2004, 05:14:53 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13235 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13235)
The motorhome industry is to small for the Japanese. No big manufacturers or investors are interested in this size industry, thats why you don't see any of the big automakers in the business anymore. They just like the engine and chassie part because it also works on trucks. Thats the other reason why you don't see a large varity of conponent parts. We think this is a big industry but it is actually a small business when it comes to manufacturing numbers. Auto companies stop making certain models when they can't sell 50,000 a year. .
Title: Re: Motorhome Industry Regulation
Post by: Bill Gabler on December 01, 2004, 05:35:48 pm
Yahoo Message Number: 13239 (http://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Country-Coach-Owners/conversations/messages/13239)
Well said George. I actually liked cars in the 50s when they actually could tell one model from the other.