Skip to main content
Topic: Toyo Tires M144 (Read 1818 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Toyo Tires M144

Yahoo Message Number: 106990
Hi All,

Need to replace my tag tires. I have two Micheline XZA2 on the front with some cracking that i want to move to tag position. Has anyone with an Allure 470 put Toyo M144's on the front. I am considering going to 315 80r 22.5 from the existing 295 80's. My Allure is a 2007 470. Any thoughts greatly appreciated. I like my Michelins but I have them on my coach and have 50,000 miles on them and they are already cracking.

The price for the Michelins is also crazy.

Thanks for the responses and happy trails.

David and Paula
2007 Allure 470
31556

Re: Toyo Tires M144

Reply #1
Yahoo Message Number: 106992
The tires on the tag should be the same diameter of the drive tires. But considering the loaded radius is around a half inch difference, I have no clue as to how much weight will be transferred from the duals to the Tags. Now I have read that a few Magna owners had to have something installed to adjust the weight distribution between the Duals and Tags, because the tags were either over loaded or not carrying the proper percentage of weight. On my Intrigue the tags are carrying 500 lbs more than designed, but as I have a 6000lb margin I have never considered the issue worth the effort. :TWI 2004 Intrigue 11731

Re: Toyo Tires M144

Reply #2
Yahoo Message Number: 106993
I had Dickman tires install Toyo M 144 on the front as they rated them very high. Have 5000 miles and doing great. After doing some research I'm hearing that the sidewall cracking issue on Toyo may show up after 5 years as compared to Michelin lasting longer. Will wait to see as I just installed 4 new duals with Michelin.

Buddy Bordes Allure 470 37 ft Sunset  #31597  running 315 on all tires

Re: Toyo Tires M144

Reply #3
Yahoo Message Number: 107000
I have the Toyos on my 09 Allure and for the money you can't beat them! They may ride a little stiffer than others on the steers but more responsive.

Dennis 09 Allure 470

Re: Toyo Tires M144

Reply #4
Yahoo Message Number: 107001
I have 12R 22.5 on my tags. (BF Goodrich ST230's that I installed on my steers about a year ago when we had two Michelin XZE*'s damaged by Pot Holes. Michelin shortage, so limited availability. The BF Goodrich were covered under the FMCA tire program, as Michelin makes BF Goodrich.)

Before this years trip, we put 6 XZA2 295/80 22.5 on the coach, movie the ST230's to the tag, as I wanted the less jarring ride of the XZA2's.

I called and talked with OMC before doing this, and they confirmed that the Tag was totally independent from the Drive and or Steers. (I had been concerned about leveling, and ride hight, but the leveler's have not impact on the Tag's, they adjust independently. And, the 12R vs 295/80 of these brands, are very close to each other size wise.)

Rickman's are fans of Toyo's. They buy them in bulk, and IMO it's their standard go to tire due to both they'll do the job, and provide the highest profit margins. Tokyo's are good tires, but the are made for the trucking industry, and they have as stiff as ride as the Michelin XZE*'s that I just removed. This according to two coach owners I know that have had both of these tires on their coaches.

I wanted higher energy efficiency, as every bit helps, and a bit less stiff riding tire. The Toyo's were not in my top 3 tires. ( 1) Michelin XZA2's; 2) BF Goodrich ST230's; 3) Continental (Forget the model.). All of these were in the proper load range for my coach.) If the Hankook AH12's were available in the sizes I wanted, I would have considered 6 of these on the Drive/Tag, and let the ST230's age out until replacement. They get many positive votes from owners of coaches similar to mine, and I trust the input from these owners.

I had trouble with Dicman's. Was called a liar in writing to American Express. I do not feel they treated me in either a professional or fair manner. They cost me money. The salesman did not honor my telling him that age of tires is important to RV owners. And that we'd need to 'Agree to disagree.' about this. He actually put a note into the invoice, that 'Age of tire is not guaranteed.'. However, he never sent me that invoice via Email as he said he would. It was not until I disputed the tires for multiple reasons, main being age and not being more energy efficient then the existing Michelin XZE*'s that I was replacing, that they sent a copy to American Express with that comment on the invoice. If I had seen this at time of order, I would have called back and cancelled it at that time. The Manager, who called me a liar in writing to American Express, was also more interested in trying to educate me on 'Tires don't age in the warehouse.' - and just now much more that he and the Salesman knew about tires then RV owners. Ego was evident over the phone.

For these reasons, I personally will never do business or recommend Dickman Tires. Regardless of their reputation and many happy RV owners. Including Country Coach owners. Next time I'm in the region, I will go to Les Schwab Corporate Headquarters in person, and let them know what Dickman did to me. I still may even take them to Small Claim's court, as a matter of principal. But admit that my wife is not as interested in me doing this as I was....

Best to all, and good luck on your tire choice,

Smitty
04 Allure Sold to a nice new owner! Now enjoying a 07 Magna Rembrandt 45' ISX600 #6775
"We're ONDROAD for THEJRNY!" (Toad and Coach license plates, say Hi if you see us!)

Re: Toyo Tires M144

Reply #5
Yahoo Message Number: 107003
I'm afraid its the other way around. I owned 4 sets of toyos and they never once cracked. The Toyos did separate and becuse of law suits Toyo will not warrant a Toyo on a CC. Was the last thing I heard. I had two 12R fail and went through so many 275 R 70's I can't recall, but it was around 4 sets. I finally got fed up and went with Continentals 275 R 80 for the Allure, and Later on 315's for the Intrigue after the Michelins and Toyos had failed. I'm back with Michelins on the front when one of my Continentals went out of round. And I will say the XZA2 has a superior ride. But doesn't compare with the XZ2 set I had that cracked after 39 months or so. All I can recommend if you live in a dry climate at higher altitudes keep your tires covered. TWI 2004 Intrigue 11731.

Re: Toyo Tires M144

Reply #6
Yahoo Message Number: 107016
Sorry I forgot to sign out properly, and for the typo's. It was Dickman's, as in Bob Dickman's. Not 'Rickman's or any other missed placed letters. Wife was driving, and I was typing not so well on my cell phone:)!

Cracking of tires is always an interesting group of threads. For sure, some Michelin owners have had problems with tire cracking at very young ages. We had about 6 1/2 years on our Michelin XZE*'s when we removed them. The Tire Manager at TCI Tire Center in Lakeside, CA (Well known gentlemen in the Southern California area, and an avid RV'er and Jeep'er too!) Spent 20 minutes on a crawler with flashlight inspecting our tires. It was his opinion, that we would have been good for another season of travel on the 6 remaining (2 newer BF Goodrich ST230's on the steers.) XZE*'s. He said if it was his coach, he would go for another year. Then spend the money to have them dismounted and inspected from the inside too, before deciding to keep or replace. (He chuckled and said he does not pay for dismounting and balancing, and his XZE2's were 8 1/2 years old.). My wife and I had agreed to a 6-7 year replacement cycle, budgeted for it, and consider it sort of as added insurance to replace at that age.

No signs of other then very mild surface cracking, visible but not measurable in a few locations.

After reading soo many threads on Michelin cracking, I've come to three conclusions:
1) Many people run their tires under inflated for their loads.
2) Many people never protect their tires from UV. (Shading type covers, and or say Aerospace 303, or similar UV protecting product.)
3) Even so, tires that are properly cared for, and inflated, still crack. More so it seems with the XRV, then other models.

Way above my pay grade to give an explanation for the 'why's' of number 3 :)!

No cracking for us so far with our vast experience of one set of Michelin's. And have not idea what I'd do if I do experience this kind of problem in the future.

Best to all, and my proper signature sign out below!

Smitty

04 Allure 31017 40'
04 Allure Sold to a nice new owner! Now enjoying a 07 Magna Rembrandt 45' ISX600 #6775
"We're ONDROAD for THEJRNY!" (Toad and Coach license plates, say Hi if you see us!)

 

Re: Toyo Tires M144

Reply #7
Yahoo Message Number: 107017
I've been asked any number of times if I use tire care products on my tires and have been warned they can cause early deterioration on Michelin tires due to their high natural rubber content. TWI 2004 intrigue 11731