Re: ISL and Allison and Jake Brake setting options?
Reply #15 –
Yahoo Message Number: 80219
Hi All - Thanks to you all for your posts, and for the few PM's I've received too - much appreciated. A few would have helped me more, if I knew for sure that the engine in your coaches had ISL's or Cat's. For example, some 04 to 06 Intrigues could have either. A Big Cat Jake, is much difference then an ISL's Jake...
I've concluded that I may not fully understand how my specific coaches ISL and Jake are interacting with each other. Thought I did, but enough comments have popped up that makes me really wonder if I do.
For example, it is possible I'm not seeing the Jake activate while in cruise control, because the cut in speed is too high for what the Allison will allow RPM's wise. So, I will test this on my next monthly exercise the rig drive, on a hill I know and setting the cruise to 50 to see what happens with Jake activation then.
Another example of where I may not be clear, one that Don pointed out to me, is the actual gear that Allison allows a Jake assist to downshift to. May not be the indicated 4 on the panel. He suggested I set the Silverleaf to display the actual Allison gear, and see what gear is kicking in. Very possible in some of my applications, that it is in 5th, though the trans panel shows 4 as the default gear for Jake.
Last assumption that may be wrong. When I'm say going down a grade in High Jake Mode, at say 35-40, and I hit the down shift to 3 - I don't think it is downshifting. (Will test this, when displaying the actual gear on the Silverleaf).
I understand the strong nudges to me, and other readers of a thread like this, to not try and 'out think' the engineers... Well, I have a few thoughts about this, as I work in aerospace with many 'engineers'. I also suspect Norcold and Workhorse had 'engineers' involved with those product failures - so I'm a bit calloused by 'engineers as all knowing' in general. I do respect the trade, but they are human and I always look out for myself, family and friends.
That being said, most of your message to me and others is the SEVERE DANGER of braking and maintaining control in mountain situations. I TOTALLY AGREE AND THANK YOU FOR BEING SURE I (and others) UNDERSTAND THIS.
I've heard enough feedback, to go do some more fact finding on what my rig is doing, and see if it is doing what I think it was... Then, I can reflect a bit more and see what I feel is the right choice.
I do appreciate all of the input, and cautions - some worded a bit more frankly then I feel was warranted. But, choose to believe it was done with good intent.
Best to all,
Smitty
04 Allure 31017 ISL